Species

Grey Parrots, CITES and the limits of a trade quota

Export quotas for wild-caught Grey Parrots continued while wild populations fell. What a quota does and does not count, and what changed in 2016.

A Grey Parrot perched among palm fronds in profile, pale grey with a scalloped pattern to the feathers and a bright red tail.
Grey Parrot in palm forest. Photo Daniel Onneweer · source · CC-BY

The counter-example is worth holding beside it: the Echo Parakeet on Mauritius came back from a handful of birds, and it took decades of work on one island, not a decision about a quota.

The African Grey Parrot is long-lived, slow to reproduce, highly intelligent and in enormous demand as a pet. That combination makes it close to the worst possible candidate for regulated commercial harvest from the wild, and for many years it was subject to exactly that.

The mechanism

Under CITES the species was listed on Appendix II, which allows commercial international trade provided exports are within quotas set by exporting states and are certified as non-detrimental to wild populations. On that basis wild-caught Grey Parrots continued to be exported from West and Central Africa, while survey work across much of the range recorded steep declines and local disappearances.

The tension is not hard to see. A system that permits trade so long as it is judged sustainable depends on the judgement, and the judgement was being made against evidence that pointed the other way.

What a quota does not count

The deeper problem is that an export quota measures the wrong thing. It counts birds legally exported. It does not count:

  • birds that die during trapping;
  • birds that die in holding, often in crowded and unsuitable conditions, before export;
  • birds that die in transit;
  • birds exported illegally, outside the quota entirely;
  • nest sites destroyed to reach chicks, since nest trees are frequently felled or cut open.

Each of those is a real cost to the wild population, and none appears in the number the system regulates. A quota of a given size therefore corresponds to a removal from the wild that is substantially larger, by a multiplier that is not reliably known.

The nest-tree point deserves particular attention, because it is not a one-off loss. A mature tree with a suitable cavity is a limiting resource for a hole-nesting parrot, and destroying it removes breeding capacity for decades regardless of how many birds are taken from it.

What CITES is for

It is tempting to conclude from this that CITES failed. A fairer statement is that CITES was being asked to do something it is not designed for.

It regulates trade. It is not a conservation agency, it does not manage habitat, it does not enforce within borders, and its listing decisions are made by parties with their own interests in the outcome. Expecting it to function as the primary protection for a heavily traded species is expecting the wrong instrument to do the job, and the disappointment that follows is partly a category error.

That said, the instrument does have a stronger setting, and the argument was about whether to use it.

What changed

In 2016 the Grey Parrot was moved to Appendix I, which prohibits commercial international trade in wild-caught individuals. That is the outcome the earlier quota decisions had declined to reach, and it removed the legal export pathway altogether.

It is worth being clear about what that did and did not achieve. Habitat loss across the range continues, illegal trapping continues, and a slow-breeding parrot does not recover on a policy timescale. The listing changed the legal position. Whether the populations follow is a separate question, answerable only by counting birds.

Common questions

What is CITES?

The Convention on International Trade in Endangered Species of Wild Fauna and Flora: an international agreement that regulates cross-border trade in listed species. It is a trade regulation instrument, not a conservation body, which is a distinction that matters for what it can be expected to do.

What was the situation with Grey Parrots?

The African Grey Parrot Psittacus erithacus sat on Appendix II, the listing that permits regulated commercial trade under export quotas. So legal shipments of trapped birds left West and Central Africa year after year, at the same time as survey work in the range states was recording steep declines and local disappearances.

What does an export quota actually count?

Birds legally exported. It does not count birds that die during trapping, in holding, or in transit before export; it does not count illegal exports; and it does not count the destruction of nest trees, which are often felled or cut open to reach chicks. The quota is therefore a floor on the take, not a measure of it.

How large is the mortality before export?

High, and variably reported. Trapping methods, crowded holding conditions and long transport all cause losses, and the number of birds removed from the wild to deliver one bird to a buyer is considerably more than one.

Has anything changed?

Yes. In 2016 the species was moved up to Appendix I, the listing that ends legal commercial export of birds taken from the wild. The stronger setting had been available throughout the earlier argument; what changed was the willingness to use it.

Is the species recovering?

An Appendix I listing removes one pressure. Habitat loss and illegal trapping continue, and a slow-breeding, long-lived parrot recovers slowly. The listing changed the legal position, not the population.